

About Pencil Pies
My name is Beth Herbert. I started Pencil Pies as a way to carry on my mom's homemade pie legacy. Named after my mom’s maiden name (Pencil), Pencil Pies is a celebration of family traditions. While working full time as a registered nurse in a cardiology office, my love for creating delicious, homemade treats has always been at the heart of my kitchen. I am thrilled to share these handcrafted pies with you, bringing a touch of home and happiness to every bite.


Delivery Info
You can purchase your items online and pick them up at my home in Mason, OH.
At the Secure Checkout page, you‘ll be able to choose pick up date and time. I do prefer 3 days notice, but text me in a pinch. Also, you will soon be able to pick up or order at The Deerfield Farmer's Market in Mason.

Contact Me
Please feel free to contact me for questions or special requests.
Pickup hours:
6PM - 9PM Mon-Thurs
9AM - 6PM Fri-Sat
12PM - 6PM Sun